Contributors

Friday, February 18, 2011

Notes From The Front in Wisconsin

from John Waxey...

Markadelphia has asked me to put down some thoughts and my experiences on what is currently happening in Madison, Wisconsin because I happen to be right in the middle of it (literally). I am not watching from my porch or re-hashing what I see on the local and national news, I am on the front line amongst the crowds at the Capital. The reason I am there is that I am on the faculty of two local state institutions and have been working in the Wisconsin system for the last 12 years. Furthermore, my wife is a nurse at UW Hospital and both of us will be substantially impacted by Scott Walker's budget repair bill. Let's start with some facts about the situation with UW system workers.

1. I have been working with a 3% salary furlough for the past two years. A 4% pay increase that was approved 4 years ago was rescinded two years ago meaning that I am making the same salary that I made 4 years ago minus the 3%. It's not complicated to see that my salary is not increasing with the rising cost of living and hasn't done so for several years.

2. The budget repair bill will shave another 7% off of my salary leaving me with an overall 10% reduction in my salary. This means overall that for a composite full-time position (it's split between two institutions), I will make approximately 22,500 before taxes this year. That is with a Masters degree and being nearly finished with a doctorate.

You might ask why do I keep the job. Fair enough question and the answer is that my retirement package and health care benefits, in part, make up for the lousy pay. So, the comments I hear on Fox News and by people who are annoyed with the protests that state workers are living high off the hog and have been for years is not part of my experience. What I have experienced is constant compromise, pay reductions and class size increase since the fiscal disaster brought upon us by the Bush administration.

I get that we all have to sacrifice and I am willing to do my part, but remember that my wife will also be affected by this repair bill, so my house gets hit twice. Add to that this bill also takes away my hard-fought right to collectively bargain. Unlike the private sector, we do not get merit pay, we may not ask for raises, we do not have the opportunity for overtime (I'm not sure the last time I spent only 40 hours a week working during the school year) and the only opportunity we have to ask for even cost of living increases is in collective bargaining. What Walker wants us to do is to just shut-up and take what is given without question or complaint. There is no way to address work-place safety without the collective bargaining process. In essence, he wants to run the state like the private sector, but not allow us to be treated like workers in the private sector. That's unfair.

Walker's argument is that we are simply being asked to contribute more to our benefits, but that is without consideration to what our salaries are. By most studies, we, the workers of Wisconsin are underpaid by some 8% already by comparison to the private sector considering experience and education and that is just in general. University of Wisconsin System workers are dramatically behind on salary compared to other colleges and universities. Furthermore, he suggests this bill is to address shortfalls in the budget. What does collective bargaining have to do with budget shortfalls? What does forcing unions to vote each year on whether they should continue to exist or not have to do with budget shortfalls? What does eliminating mandatory union dues have to do with budget shortfalls? It doesn't have anything to do with it. Plain and simple, Walker wants to see unions collapse so that he (and future governors I suppose) can dictate the livelihood of the 177,000 state workers in Wisconsin. We are to just trust that he knows what's best for us and our families. That is not reasonable and is not the limited government that he and his Republican pals have promised.

One last thing for now...I find it infuriating that people who are backing Walker are referring to him as courageous. This is a man who has hidden from the people he intends to screw with this bill. He goes to Green Bay to tour a factory and meet with a dozen people while 13,000 people are protesting his power grab. He didn't come to the public workers of Wisconsin to discuss his bill, he won't face them and his excuse is he has nothing to offer. He is a coward by definition and a poor leader (even if you agree with his politics). Mr. Walker seems to think that his being elected meant that his agenda was given the A-Ok by everyone and that he would not actually have to govern, just enforce. Of course understanding the difference between those two things may have been covered in his senior year at Marquette, you know, the one that he dropped out of pulling a mighty 2.59 average. That was a cheap shot, but it also illustrates a failing I am seeing in most politicians these days. That is, the attitude that winning an election entitles them to push one agenda or another.

In Walker's first 6 weeks, he has proposed 117.2 million in tax breaks that will affect mostly wealthier people, he has attempted to cut my pay by another 7% and destroy my right to collectively bargain. He has pissed off nearly 200,000 workers and their families by not governing but trying only to enforce his un-creative and narrow-minded approach to repairing a deficit that is largely manufactured. This is why I am at the Capital today and tomorrow. God and Ed Schultz save us all.

19 comments:

GuardDuck said...

Perhaps I missed it hidden here, but I didn't see a single word about you just being happy you have a job.

You should be in this economy. I know I am and I could throw out a litany of private sector grumbling to match yours.

Thirty odd years ago a guy named Reagan had a novel solution to a bunch of troublesome air traffic controllers. You think the general public won't applaud a similar action in light of their current economic troubles?

johnwaxey said...

GuardDuck, you are right, let me amend my blog, I am happy to have a job, but I am not happy that I am forced to live paycheck to paycheck, especially when the fiscal disaster in Wisconsin is being trumped up by the Walker administration to justify cutting my wages more. I believe in sacrifice for the greater good, but I don't see the same sacrifices being asked of others. State workers in Wisconsin are low hanging fruit and easily forced to the will of the administration. Unions are the only protection we have other than walking away from the job and trying to find other work in an already tight market.

As for the air traffic controllers, you were dealing with a couple thousand people, here we are talking about a helluva lot more people to fire. And before anyone gets too excited about it, they had better consider where their childcare is going to come from for the next year while you replace those teachers. And you better consider the quality of those teachers who will take the place of the current batch. That solution will cost this country/state billions of dollars and we will all live with the ramifications for having green teachers educate our children.

GuardDuck said...

John,

As to the ATC: I had already seen this morning reference to such a solution. I only stole it and added it here to show that there is perception that the 'low hanging fruit' is ripe for picking. I agree that such a response would cause more problems than it would solve.

I too have been forced to live paycheck to paycheck. But I have less empathy for your plight as I would be thrilled if I had been only asked to reduce my pay by 10%. As it is, last year I had a 50% pay cut. How is that for seeing sacrifices asked of others? How can you not see it when the unemployment rate is so high? How can you not see it when the underemployment rate is so high? How can you not see it, unless you have ignored the effects of the very same fiscal disaster you have decried?

You ask what does collective bargaining have to do with budget shortfalls? It has everything to do with it. The state workers are the main cost item on a state budget. Just like the employees are the main cost item on a company budget. In the private sector, when the income stops coming in, the employer has to cut employees. How would you want a state budget fixed? Raise taxes? Cut expenses? Those are the two options. That's twice as many choices as a private sector employer has.

The reason there is such backlash against public sector collective bargaining is their intransigent refusal to cut when the budget requires it. If your union won't budge when the budget has to be trimmed, then you are bound to find some people calling for some union busting.

My own union can often be it's members own worst enemy in that regard. It's refusal to bow to the economic realities of the company has forced the company to utilize outside contractors on a large scale - meaning union job growth has staled. New jobs are contractors and the union is a dying entity.

Anonymous said...

Let's have some facts, shall we?

http://www.teacher-world.com/teacher-salary/wisconsin.html

http://www.jsonline.com/watchdog/dataondemand/33534649.html

http://www.postcrescent.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/99999999/APC0110/399990170&appSession=368282737443554

Anonymous said...

There are a lot of teachers making a he'll of a lot of money. It appears that the trick is to go into administration or library media.

http://www.jsonline.com/watchdog/dataondemand/33534649.html

johnwaxey said...

GuardDog, I feel for your situation and whatever caused your employer to ask you to cut your salary by 50% must have been extreme. It sounds like your union let you down and that is too bad. You and I have more in common than you let on. No one is saying there aren't bad unions and bad union reps out there, but that doesn't mean that unions shouldn't exist and that workers shouldn't have a voice in the workplace.

Your response is very telling to me in the sense that it reeks of fear. You talk about unemployment and underemployment. Unemployment in Wisconsin is less than it is in many states and people here will do what it takes to make a living whether it is getting a new job or fighting for their current job. There are many alternatives for balancing a budget including cuts, growing revenues and raising taxes. Walker has turned down several opportunities to grow industry in Wisconsin and has let companies leave the state. The truth is that we need more from our leadership than the same tired approaches (that are rooted to an unrealistic political ideology)to these problems. We have a 32 dollar per person shortfall in Wisconsin. I know people who blow this weekly on drinks at the bar. If minor increases in taxes allow a better way of life for all Wisconsinites, then I support tax increases. Just because Democrats and Republicans don't want to face that reality doesn't mean that it shouldn't be done.

I have seen people hurting and have watched my dollar buy less and less the last 5 years, but things are getting better. The stock market is up, unemployment is going down in some sectors and companies are posting profits, some of them quite large. I am not going to buy into the new fear mongering of the Republicans. They have replaced the panic of terrorism with the panic of the economic situation. The recession will end and life will return to a pre-Bush state at some point. What is important is not to let people like Walker take our rights out of fear. Fear is a powerful tool and as long as someone is afraid, they will do anything for someone who offers them a solution. Walker is asking us to be terrified of a budget deficit that is largely a worst-case-scenario construct. All we have to do is give up our rights. Let papa government make it all right and you don't have to be scared anymore. The difference in Wisconsin among working people of the private and public sector unions is that we don't buy the lie, we won't be afraid and we won't give up our rights.

sw said...

The Wisconsin unions don’t seem to understand that Gov. Walker is just following what they have always asked for. Wealth redistribution. They say that the wealthy should share with the poor. Well, right now, the private sector worker makes about half of what the public sector worker does. Seems like the wealthy public sector should share.

Kind of sucks when it is YOUR wealth being redistributed.

Anonymous said...

http://maciverinstitute.com/2011/02/study-shows-even-after-limits-public-employee-benefits-would-be-extremely-generous/

So you're griping because the cost to you of your health plan would now be only the second lowest in the midwest, instead of the lowest?

Anonymous said...

Mr Waxey, I am also a citizen in WI, and Gov Walker certainly hasn't pissed off this worker or family. And both my spouse and I are (forced) union members.

You want Walker to govern and be patient? I have some recent catch phrases that come from your camp:

"Elections have consequences."

and

"We won."

Both uttered by your fearless leader, Barack Obama.

So I say, Go Scott GO!

Anonymous said...

Did you get a fake doctor's note to bring back to your supervisor??

This story really gives good teachers a bad name.

http://www.theblaze.com/stories/doctors-hand-out-excuses-for-protesters-sick-of-gov-walker/

Anonymous said...

What is important is not to let people like Walker take our rights...

What rights are those? Does the state government have the right to hire non-union teachers? Do the taxpayers have the right to refuse to meet whatever terms the unions they don't have the right to avoid hiring demand?

So I guess the "rights" you expect are the "rights" for your union to demand whatever it wants, and those who deal with the consequences and foot the bill to have no other options and no recourse. Sure, they can put their kids in private school... just as long as they continue paying whatever you demand anyway.

Apparently you think "rights" are something that only union members should be allowed to have.

Santa said...

Something tells me that Anonymous is lying again. That's the second time you have been caught in one. Naughty naughty!

Anonymous said...

Santa, you make statements like our President. "Something tells me that Anon is lying again." and is caught. What lie and what proof?

Anonymous said...

Waxey, your attack on Gov Walker's education is comical. He didn't finish college and was elected governor. You almost have a doctorate and make less than a middle manager at Walmart.

Anonymous said...

I haven't received a cost of living increase in five fucking years. Inflation is rearing it's ugly head. I am going backwards.

Tell ya what, you live within your means, and I will too. Deal?

Anonymous said...

""There is no way to address work-place safety without the collective bargaining process. ""

Have you heard of OSHA?

There's enough laws on the books to deal with work place safety. Do you seriously think the private sector are running businesses with wet floors and no place to put sharps?

Pha leese.

Anonymous said...

The Smallest Minority

Look for Marxie on your left and down a page or so....

"In your case, there's a couple of years suggesting anything you say or suggest is pure Grade A monkeyshit conjecture."
Wednesday, December 23, 2009, 2:34:46

Larry said...

Ed Schultz? Ed "Potato Head" Schultz??!! Are you on drugs? If so, why the hell aren't you sharing with the rest of us?

Anonymous said...

http://dailycaller.com/2011/02/21/wisconsins-teachers-make-a-little-more-money-than-theyre-letting-on/#ixzz1EcVyuABq