Contributors

Wednesday, January 25, 2012

SOTU Post Mortem

As he always does, President Obama gave a great speech last night to Congress. A few things struck me as interesting.

He seemed to back away from partisan attacks (odd, in an election year) using the word "American" over 80 times while making sure to say that we share certain values. That's very optimistic and, from him, I'd expect nothing less. I guess I don't really share his sunny outlook but I do appreciate his populist tone.

What I saw on display last night was the very obvious and monumentally titanic reluctance to accept that the federal government plays a key role in our society and in the world at large. The president presented a balanced and pragmatic approach to government and the private sector. Yet, anytime the government doing something was mentioned, the Republicans sat on their hands. Honestly, they looked like stubborn little children because, sadly, "key role" has somehow magically transformed itself into socialism. This was very apparent in Governor Daniels response and the commentary by folks like Ari Fleischer after the speech.

As Speaker Boehner put it, pre-speech, "The president and the GOP are from different planets." Yes, this is true. The latter resides on one that is a largely created work of fiction that does not exist in reality.

It's obvious to me that the GOP in Congress are going to do everything in their power to deny him any sort of successes this year. Fair enough, I suppose, given that this is an election year. Yet, it's also fair of him to make Congress (and that's D's and R's alike) his opponent. With approval ratings 30 points lower than his, they offer a stark contrast which he illustrated several times last night by saying, "Put it on my desk and I'll sign it." They won't, of course, and that clearly shows which of the two parties actually want to do something. I think we may see some surprises this year in the voting booth come November. Key question to consider: just how little do the American people want Congress to do? We're going to find out.

Although not directly mentioned in his speech, I was also please to hear about another SEAL team success in Somalia. I was wondering why the president told SecDef Panetta, as he was walking in, "Good job, today!" Now we know. This president has been highly skilled in the area of his many duties that fall under the mantle of "Commander in Chief."

The president set an upbeat tone for his reelection campaign and, to a much larger degree, America as a whole last night in the State of the Union. In looking at it in comparison to what Mitt Romney and Newt Gingrich have been saying about America, one has to wonder if Speaker Boehner's comment could actually be broadened to two different universes.

12 comments:

juris imprudent said...

About those billionaires paying less taxes than their secretaries...

http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/politics/2011/09/fact-check-the-richtheir-secretaries-and-taxes/

rld said...

http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5hmMd4Wbbpt4uXU36QnBNy3rmXQdg?docId=8b722f1b0bfc42768fd73804663b8955

AP fact check

6Kings said...

http://m.atr.org/article.php?id=6700

Americans for Tax Reform fact check

don said...

http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-503544_162-20029581-503544.html

Uh Oh...

Mark Ward said...

So, we're just trying to prove him wrong, then? No interest in critical thinking and examining what he got right? Oh, maybe NONE of it was right. Is that it? As long as each of you are being logical and rational:)

don, saw that...might turn it into a post!

juris imprudent said...

Honestly M, I don't expect much out of any President's SOTU and rarely do they exceed my expectations. In my life it has turned into a ritual of clichés and fabulist promises punctuated by robotic applause and cinematic excess. It is everything that is wrong with the Cult of Personality surrounding the Presidency. Not that I expect a Hero Worshipper like you to understand.

rld said...

So citing factchecks and politifact-type sites isn't critical thinking? You reference stuff like that all the time.

Larry said...

This president has been highly skilled in the area of his many duties that fall under the mantle of "Commander in Chief."

Where "highly skilled" means being that when the military or intelligence services have discovered the location, have developed a plan, and then after informing him of the facts and asking for permission to proceed, says, "Okay. Do it." Highly skilled, indeed.

Mark Ward said...

for permission to proceed, says, "Okay. Do it." Highly skilled, indeed.

Uh, this is what I am talking about...

http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0511/55022.html

and this...

http://www.nypost.com/p/news/national/bam_ordered_backup_in_case_of_hostile_pzqJpntrJKEUwdUoVbmkwI

But Obama -- concerned that there would not be enough troops to fight their way out of Abbottabad if the Pakistani military or police intervened -- decided to assign two additional helicopters carrying soldiers to hover nearby, the official said.

One of those backup helicopters was needed when a chopper assigned to the assault team was damaged.

6Kings said...

M, you are a complete dupe! Obama, the master of nothing but rhetoric, offers a tactic that practitioners and experts of the trade didn't already think of ?! That is funny....possible as in aliens might exist possible but not bloody likely.

Hook, line, and sinker!

GuardDuck said...

Only in Markadelphia-land.

The life long politician Obama was too incompetent to know what kind of political message was going to be unveiled when he stepped on stage to address the nation in Arizona last year.

But! The never served in uniform Obama is an expert military adviser to seal team 6 and special operations air commanders.

Boy, that kind of commander in chief doesn't come along very often. Thank providence for that.

Larry said...

And when he was a senator, this same highly skilled military commander-in-chief-in-waiting proclaimed the surge in Iraq to be futile. Just before it worked...